To Live in an Age of Optimism

Above is a scene from the MAS*H episode “Run for the Money.” Charles Emerson Winchester III has taken notice of a wounded soldier who is constantly degraded by his commanding officer and fellow comrades for his stuttering. Rather than argue back with those poking fun, he buries his nose into comic books because why should he read anything else? He’s been called a dummy for so long that he considers himself exactly that. Enter Winchester, who notices that the soldier’s IQ is actually well above normal. This kid is no fool. While Winchester admits to reading some Captain Marvel, himself, he explains that comic books are these lesser stories, and he hands the soldier a beautiful copy of Herman Melville’s Moby Dick. It, he continues, is something worthy of the kid’s intellect.

Reflexively, I rolled my eyes, pissed that what I consider to be my favorite sitcom of all time had made yet another crack on my beloved comic book medium–this was not the first in the show’s run. Comic books are an easy target, but MAS*H was supposed to be smarter than that. “Fuck you,” I said not so under my breath. But the more I thought about it, the more the bit made sense. I’m so used to these jokes coming from today’s entertainment, but this was a different time. With the episode airing in season eleven, the last of the series, and the Korean War ending in 1953, I’d place the time as the same year. What were comics like in the early 50s? What ideas were being explored? Did the themes found in DC’s Captain Marvel come anywhere close to those addressed in Melville’s maritime tome? Simply put, no.


The most popular comics in 1953 were under heavy scrutiny under the public’s eye–only a year later Fredric Wertham would publish his Seduction of the Innocent. Westerns, Romance, Crime, Horror. and War stories had taken dominance over shelf space, beating down the once successful superhero genre. Of course the men and women in tights still had their adventures, but the readership dropped tremendously during this time–the waning would wax once more come the 1960s.

These stories, while entertaining, did not offer much in terms of intellectual substance (strictly speaking for mainstream publications). Because of this, Charles’ dismissal and the frequent other quips can be forgiven because, well, they weren’t exactly off base. This stigma that comics were but pop drivel last for many, many years, surpassing even the moment in which they became far more than the preconceived notions. 1960s Marvel deserves a great majority of the credit for turning the wind-whipped tide as they started creating comics that were more relevant, such as continuing the ongoing discussion of racial inequality through X-Men.

Flash forward several decades to the present day, and the comics market looks a whole lot different. Today we see writers exploring concepts like String Theory in Jonathan Hickman’s Avengers/New Avengers, conducting multi-year experiments on the downfall of humanity and the lengths we will go to in order to either aid or hinder the transformation in Robert Kirkman’s The Walking Dead, to unearthing what it means, once we dig through the layers of public and private expectations, to be family and to care for those we love even when those we love hurt us the most in Brian K. Vaughan’s Saga, not only gender but racial and religious equality for “minorities” in G. Willow Wilson’s Ms. Marvel, and creators attempting to push LGBTQ characters past representations to the ultimate standing: characters.

Don’t get me wrong, the exploration of these aspects is by no means exclusive to the current month to month production; however, the degree to which we see them both quantitative and qualitative is.


Hickman brings up a phenomenal point in Secret Wars #1 when Rocket Raccoon states, “I do remember when comics were only a dollar. A dollar’s worth of crap!”

Clearly, there is some generalization, but for the most part he is spot on. We have transcended the age of comics as strictly entertainment and now find ourselves in an era where comics can be taken seriously because they take themselves seriously (or, when the story permits, they have the know-how to restrain seriousness to generate a higher level of sincerity).

As both an English Literature graduate and a lover of the comics medium, I’ve seen a grotesque number of attempts to draw a line between the two. Moby Dick stands in one corner, while Batman is cast to the opposite. But what happens when Neil Gaiman enters the ring with Sandman or years later Marvel drops a perfectly complex multiuniversal Avengers story on our asses–and don’t you discount the Warren Ellis Moon Knight they have tucked away for a rainy day. No longer is the winner as clear. Let oddsmakers struggle with their ratios, my bet’s on both.

When talking about our article plans for the week, several of the NBC! staff mentioned they were preparing to write a piece on comics coming down the pike. And that got me thinking. Fans tend to look to the past most often when the present and future is filled with nothing but dark skies. I think it is safe to store away the umbrella and retrieve the sun block. Meet me at the beach, won’t you?

27 thoughts on “To Live in an Age of Optimism”

  1. I agree that we are in the Golden Age of comics (and TV for that matter). Some people who don’t read comics (and don’t watch TV) make ignorant comments about the quality of both. I think that TV’s quality has far surpassed films while comics have a long way to go to catch up to prose. That is mostly because prose has had a few hundred years head start. I believe that there is value in all mediums and it does infuriate me when people bastardize comics. I think that comics really have a great value in that they provide a quick reading alternative to prose. Quality just depends on who is doing the creating.

    I’ve had 2 girlfriends in the past really shit on the comics in my life with quotes like. “They made you a better boy” when i suggested that comics had made me a better man. Not to mention spotting graphic novels on my book shelf and saying “more of that stuff” while laughing. Eventual deal breakers. And now comics are in??

    Normally the people that really dump on comics are connoisseurs of some high brow entertainment (like professional wrestling). I apologize to any wresting fans…

    1. I knew Sarah, my wife, was right when she started reading my comics and then eventually began picking out her own books.

  2. Your favorite tv show of all time is MASH? You would get along great with my grandparents. 😜 If they were still alive…😢

    Nice positive article. I dig it. What was your major in college again? 😝

      1. Bawahaaa! I’ve never seen that before, but it is fucking hilarious! 😂
        I’m doing great, actually. How have you been?
        I was just poking a bit of fun at the head dork in charge to let him know I still gotta lot of luv for him. I just hope he hasn’t been watching HOUSE OF CARDS, cuz he’s really gonna let me have it if he has. 😃

        1. Good to hear.

          I’ve been doing alright.

          Man house of cards was one of those shows that is really good but fuck that end of season one, gassing that dude. Fucked up, I had to stop watching. I mean for some reason I can take twisted shit on every other show, ha! But I thought politicians were saints,.,. ha!

              1. Seriously, all that time you guys spent on House Of Cards could’ve been spent watching The Wire & Mad Men, two shows that never fell off.

                  1. Stephen King calls Mad Men a Soap Opera but as much as I love Mr. KIng, if Mad Men is a “soap”, it just happens to be the best “soap” ever (and the only watchable one). Have you guys seen “The Americans”. Mr King and I agree on that one. One of the best shows ever!

                    1. Man, I started watching it first season and loved it but haven’t had the time to keep up. It really is like everything I’d want from a story just in terms of personal interest. Chris Ryan said on a podcast that the Americans felt like something that was transmitted from his brain to be exactly what he wanted and I’m in the same boat.

                    2. Ya, there are so many really good shows out now that it is tough to see them all. It’s pretty amazing really.

        2. By the way Sitara, have you seen True Detective Season 1 yet? Pat and I guarantee that if you do it will be one of the best things you’ve ever watched. You’re wife will even dig it. Right, Pat? Don’t answer that; I know the answer.

            1. I think you would love the atheist character. It is maybe the most genuinely scarey thing I’ve ever watched also. Don’t miss out!

      1. Seriously Gomer Pyle USMC is one of my favorite shows ever! I used to watch that shit and wonder why real people weren’t as nice as Gomer. Who gives a fuck if he was a fuck up, he was a nice dude.

    1. Haha I know it is a weird choice, but I was raised on MASH. One of the things that always stuck with me was the craft. MASH never felt like a tv show to me but rather a brilliant live performance that just so happened to be caught on camera. No other show has captured that performance magic.

      1. Ya, I think that a lot of us growing up probably just watched what our parents watched. I worked for a veterinarian after college that would always talk about Mash but I had no idea what he was talking about. It’s quite possible that whatever channel that was rerunning that show didn’t get picked up by our rabbit ears (Dad refused to get cable). We got Star Trek TNG though and Lucy!

        1. I spent a lot of time with my uncle when I was a kid, so some childhood staples were MASH, Sanford and Son, and Dragnet. I remember him having dozens for VHS tapes with hours for TV Land shows on them. Sadly, I didn’t get any Star Trek until I sought it out myself. Star War will always be my favorite, but I never understood the clash between fans. I love them both!

          1. Ya Star Wars and Star Trek are really two totally different beasts. Both have there merits. Man if I keep this up I’m going to have to…

Leave a Reply to Ukerupp Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s